Best Thanksgiving Pie Recipes From Scratch
Thanksgiving is a time for gratitude, family, and, of course, incredible food. While the turkey often takes center stage, for many, the grand finale of the meal is the array of delicious pies. There’s something truly special about a homemade pie, crafted with care from scratch.
Moving beyond store-bought options elevates your holiday feast. Creating your own pies allows you to control the ingredients, adjust flavors, and infuse each slice with personal touch. It’s a culinary journey that adds warmth and tradition to your celebration.
This article isn’t just about the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch. We’re exploring essential tools and ingredients that help you achieve bakery-quality results right in your own kitchen. Whether you’re a seasoned baker or trying your hand at pie-making for the first time, you’ll find valuable suggestions here.
We’ve curated a list of top products available on Amazon that can make your pie-baking experience smoother and more enjoyable. These items range from fundamental baking tools to high-quality ingredients. They are selected to help you create truly memorable desserts for your Thanksgiving table.
From budget-friendly basics to premium enhancements, there’s something to suit every baker’s needs and preferences. Our goal is to present an honest review of helpful items. You will be well-equipped to tackle any of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
Let’s discover the best products to help you master the art of homemade Thanksgiving pies. Prepare to impress your guests with delicious, handcrafted desserts.
—
1. Emile Henry Ruffled Pie Dish
This beautiful ceramic pie dish is a game-changer for any serious baker. Its ruffled edge isn’t just for aesthetics; it helps create a perfect crust every time. The dish is known for its excellent heat retention and even baking.
It ensures your pie crusts are golden and flaky, while fillings cook through perfectly. This product is ideal for those who prioritize both presentation and performance in their bakeware. It works wonderfully for classic pumpkin pie or a vibrant apple pie.
The Emile Henry dish transitions beautifully from oven to table. It makes serving your best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch effortless. While a premium investment, its quality and durability make it a worthwhile purchase for years of holiday baking.
You can find various colors and sizes on Amazon. This allows you to pick the perfect one for your kitchen. It truly elevates the entire pie-making and serving experience.
2. King Arthur Baking Company All-Purpose Flour
A great pie starts with a great crust, and that requires high-quality flour. King Arthur Baking Company’s All-Purpose Flour is renowned among bakers for its consistency and performance. It’s unbleached and unbromated, ensuring a pure taste.
This flour provides the ideal balance of protein for tender, flaky pie crusts. It works equally well for sweet or savory recipes. It’s a staple ingredient for any aspiring pie master tackling Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
Whether you’re making a delicate apple pie crust or a sturdy base for a pecan pie, this flour delivers reliable results. Its quality makes a noticeable difference in the final texture and taste of your homemade pies. This is a mid-range ingredient that offers excellent value.
Many bakers consider this a top choice for all their baking needs. You can easily purchase larger bags on Amazon to keep your pantry stocked. It’s an essential item for any kitchen.
3. Bob’s Red Mill Organic Pumpkin Puree
For a truly authentic pumpkin pie, the quality of your pumpkin puree is paramount. Bob’s Red Mill Organic Pumpkin Puree offers a rich, smooth texture and a naturally sweet flavor. It’s made from 100% organic pumpkin.
This product is free from added sugars or preservatives. It ensures your pumpkin pie tastes pure and wholesome. It’s perfect for those seeking to create the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch with natural ingredients.
Using a premium puree like this elevates the traditional pumpkin pie to new heights. It provides a consistent base that absorbs spices beautifully. This results in a creamy, flavorful filling that everyone will adore.
It’s a mid-range ingredient that contributes significantly to the overall quality of your pie. Check Amazon for convenient multi-packs to ensure you have enough for all your holiday baking. It’s a standout item for your pie ingredients.
4. Fisher Chef’s Naturals Pecan Halves
Pecan pie is a beloved classic, and the quality of the pecans makes all the difference. Fisher Chef’s Naturals Pecan Halves are consistently fresh, plump, and flavorful. They add a delightful crunch and buttery taste to your pie.
These pecans are perfect for arranging beautifully on top of your pie or for incorporating into the filling. Their natural sweetness enhances the rich caramel notes of a traditional pecan pie. They are a top choice for any pecan pie recipe.
Opting for high-quality pecan halves ensures your pie has the best texture and flavor. It avoids the bitterness that can sometimes come with older, lower-quality nuts. This product is a fantastic choice for creating a show-stopping dessert.
They are generally a mid-range ingredient, offering great quality for the price. Find them on Amazon in various sizes to suit your baking needs. These pecans are essential for one of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
5. Simply Organic Pumpkin Pie Spice
A well-spiced pumpkin pie is the heart of Thanksgiving. Simply Organic Pumpkin Pie Spice is a carefully balanced blend of cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg, and cloves. It delivers consistent, warm, and inviting flavors.
This organic spice blend saves you the trouble of measuring individual spices. It ensures a perfectly harmonious flavor profile every time. It’s a convenient and high-quality product for busy holiday bakers.
The vibrant aroma and taste of these fresh spices will make your pumpkin pie truly unforgettable. It’s also versatile enough to use in other fall desserts or even coffee. This spice blend is a must-have for your pantry.
This is a mid-range spice blend that offers excellent value due to its organic quality. You can easily purchase it on Amazon and keep it fresh for future baking endeavors. It’s a key ingredient for many Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
6. Rodelle Vanilla Extract
Vanilla extract is a foundational ingredient that enhances the flavor of almost any sweet dish, including pies. Rodelle Vanilla Extract is a pure, high-quality extract known for its rich and robust flavor profile. It adds depth and warmth.
Made from premium vanilla beans, this extract provides a smooth and authentic vanilla essence. It avoids the artificial taste sometimes found in cheaper alternatives. It’s an indispensable item for creating truly delicious fillings.
Whether you’re making a creamy custard pie, a sweet potato pie, or even a fruit pie, a dash of good vanilla elevates the entire recipe. It rounds out other flavors and adds a touch of elegance. This product is a baker’s secret weapon.
While a bit more premium in price, its concentrated flavor means a little goes a long way. Find various sizes of Rodelle Vanilla Extract on Amazon. It is an essential for the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
7. OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Pastry Blender
Achieving that perfectly flaky pie crust requires properly cut-in butter or shortening. The OXO Good Grips Stainless Steel Pastry Blender makes this task effortless. Its sturdy blades quickly incorporate fat into flour.
This tool prevents overworking the dough, which can lead to tough crusts. The comfortable handle makes it easy to use, even for extended periods. It’s a simple yet incredibly effective product for any serious pie maker.
It’s ideal for beginners who might struggle with using their hands or a fork to cut in butter. This ensures consistent results every time. A flaky crust is a hallmark of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
This budget-friendly tool is a fantastic investment for anyone who bakes pies regularly. It’s readily available on Amazon and will quickly become one of your most used kitchen gadgets. It is a quality tool for the price.
8. J.K. Adams Maple Wood Rolling Pin
A good rolling pin is crucial for creating uniform pie crusts. The J.K. Adams Maple Wood Rolling Pin is a classic, durable, and beautifully crafted tool. It offers a smooth, even roll for perfect dough thickness.
Made from solid maple, this rolling pin has a comfortable weight and feel. It allows for precise control as you roll out your dough. Its natural wood surface helps prevent sticking, especially when lightly floured.
This traditional style rolling pin is built to last for generations. It’s an essential for anyone committed to making their own pie crusts from scratch. It is perfect for both novice and experienced bakers.
While a premium item, its durability and performance justify the price. You can find this top-quality rolling pin on Amazon, often with different handle styles. It’s an investment for years of Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
9. Pyrex Smart Essentials Mixing Bowl Set
Every pie recipe, whether for filling or crust, starts with mixing ingredients. The Pyrex Smart Essentials Mixing Bowl Set is a versatile and durable collection of glass bowls. They are perfect for all your baking needs.
These bowls are made from non-porous glass, so they won’t absorb stains or odors. They are also microwave and dishwasher safe for easy cleaning and convenience. Their clear design allows you to easily see contents.
With various sizes included, this set can handle everything from whisking eggs to mixing large batches of pie filling. They are a fundamental item for any kitchen, especially for bakers. This product offers exceptional utility.
This budget-friendly set is an excellent value for its quality and versatility. You can easily purchase it on Amazon, and it will quickly become a go-to item in your kitchen. It’s a top choice for everyday baking tasks.
10. USA Pan Bakeware Pie Pan
For a consistently baked pie, a reliable metal pie pan is indispensable. The USA Pan Bakeware Pie Pan features a fluted surface and a non-stick coating. This ensures even heat distribution and easy release of your pies.
The unique fluted design promotes airflow, resulting in a beautifully browned and crisp bottom crust. This is often a challenge with some pie dishes. Its durable construction means it will withstand countless baking sessions.
This pan is perfect for any of your favorite Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch, from fruit pies to creamy custards. It’s a workhorse that delivers professional-quality results every time. It’s a practical and effective product.
This mid-range pie pan is a great investment for its performance and longevity. Find it on Amazon, often in different sizes. It’s a high-quality option for consistent baking.
11. Canned Tart Cherries (Oregon Fruit Products)
If you’re making a classic cherry pie, the quality of your cherries is paramount. Oregon Fruit Products Canned Tart Cherries are packed in water, not heavy syrup. They offer a bright, natural tart flavor.
These cherries are perfect for creating a vibrant, flavorful cherry pie filling. They provide that authentic taste without the hassle of pitting fresh cherries. This makes homemade cherry pie accessible year-round.
Using high-quality canned cherries ensures a consistent flavor profile and texture in your pie. It’s ideal for those who want the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch but prefer convenience for certain ingredients.
This is a mid-range ingredient that significantly impacts the taste of your cherry pie. You can purchase these on Amazon in multi-packs to always have them on hand. They are a top choice for fruit pie fillings.
12. Nellie & Joe’s Key West Lime Juice
For an authentic Key Lime Pie, there’s no substitute for real Key lime juice. Nellie & Joe’s Key West Lime Juice is made from 100% Key limes. It delivers that distinct tart and aromatic flavor.
This product saves you the tedious task of squeezing dozens of tiny Key limes. It ensures a consistent, bright flavor profile for your pie filling. It’s an absolute must-have for Key lime pie enthusiasts.
Using this high-quality juice is the secret to achieving that perfect balance of sweet and tangy. It creates a refreshing and zesty pie that stands out among other Thanksgiving desserts. It’s a fantastic option.
This is a budget-friendly ingredient that makes a huge difference in your pie’s authenticity. Find it easily on Amazon, often in larger bottles. It’s essential for making one of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
13. Ghirardelli Chocolate Premium Baking Bar
For rich and decadent chocolate pies, the quality of your chocolate is non-negotiable. Ghirardelli Chocolate Premium Baking Bar offers a deep, complex flavor and smooth melting consistency. It elevates any chocolate-based dessert.
Whether you’re making a classic chocolate cream pie or a sophisticated chocolate silk pie, this baking bar delivers. Its high cacao content ensures an intense chocolate experience. This product is a premium choice.
Using a premium chocolate like Ghirardelli ensures your pie filling is luxurious and full of flavor. It melts beautifully, creating a silky-smooth texture. This is crucial for the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
While a premium ingredient, its impact on flavor is undeniable. You can purchase Ghirardelli baking bars on Amazon in various cacao percentages. It’s a top-tier choice for chocolate lovers.
14. Organic Cane Sugar (Wholesome Sweeteners)
Sugar is a fundamental ingredient in almost all pie recipes, and choosing a quality option matters. Wholesome Sweeteners Organic Cane Sugar is unrefined and offers a clean, natural sweetness. It enhances flavors without overpowering them.
This organic cane sugar provides a subtle caramel note that complements many pie fillings. It dissolves easily and bakes consistently, contributing to perfect textures. It’s a versatile staple for any baker’s pantry.
Using organic sugar means you’re choosing a less processed option. This aligns with making the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch with wholesome ingredients. It’s a reliable and ethical choice.
This is a mid-range ingredient that offers excellent quality for everyday baking. You can find large bags of Wholesome Sweeteners Organic Cane Sugar on Amazon. It’s an essential item to have on hand.
15. Stainless Steel Measuring Cups and Spoons Set
Accurate measurements are key to successful baking, especially for pie recipes. A high-quality Stainless Steel Measuring Cups and Spoons Set is durable, precise, and easy to clean. It ensures consistent results every time.
These sets typically feature engraved measurements that won’t fade over time, unlike plastic alternatives. Their sturdy construction means they won’t bend or break with regular use. They are essential tools for any kitchen.
Having a reliable set of measuring tools is crucial for both beginners and experienced bakers. It helps maintain the delicate balance of ingredients in pie crusts and fillings. This product is a foundational baking item.
This budget-friendly set is a smart purchase for any home baker. You can find many highly-rated options on Amazon. It’s a top product for ensuring precision in your Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
16. Silicone Pie Crust Shield (Tovolo)
Preventing pie crust edges from burning while the filling cooks is a common baking challenge. The Tovolo Silicone Pie Crust Shield offers a simple and effective solution. It protects the delicate crust.
This reusable silicone shield fits various pie dish sizes and is heat resistant up to 500°F (260°C). It eliminates the need for fiddly aluminum foil, making baking less stressful. It’s a practical, problem-solving product.
It ensures your pie crust edges are perfectly golden, not charred. This allows your pie filling to cook completely without worry. This tool is a must-have for achieving a picture-perfect finish on your pies.
This budget-friendly item is a fantastic investment for any pie baker. It’s readily available on Amazon and will save you time and frustration. It’s a great choice for ensuring the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch look perfect.
17. Silicone Pastry Brush (OXO Good Grips)
A good pastry brush is essential for applying egg washes, butter, or glazes to your pie crusts. The OXO Good Grips Silicone Pastry Brush features soft, flexible bristles that hold liquids well and spread them evenly.
Unlike traditional bristle brushes, silicone brushes are hygienic and won’t shed hairs onto your food. They are also easy to clean and dishwasher safe. This product is a durable and practical kitchen tool.
It’s perfect for brushing an egg wash on your apple pie for a glossy finish or butter on your pecan pie for extra richness. This versatile tool makes many finishing touches effortless. It’s a quality product.
This budget-friendly brush is a great addition to any baker’s toolkit. You can easily find it on Amazon. It’s a top choice for adding professional touches to your Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
18. Ceramic Pie Weights (Fox Run)
For blind baking pie crusts, pie weights are indispensable. Fox Run Ceramic Pie Weights help prevent the crust from bubbling up and shrinking during pre-baking. They ensure a perfectly flat and even base.
These reusable ceramic weights distribute heat evenly, promoting a crisp bottom crust. This is crucial for custard pies, quiches, or any recipe where the filling isn’t baked as long as the crust. They are effective and easy to use.
Using pie weights results in a beautifully shaped and fully baked crust. This prepares it perfectly for your delicious fillings. It’s a simple tool that makes a significant difference in pie quality.
This budget-friendly product is a wise investment for any baker who makes pies from scratch. You can easily purchase them on Amazon. They are essential for achieving the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
19. Sweet Potato Puree (Farmer’s Market Organic)
For a creamy and flavorful sweet potato pie, a high-quality puree is key. Farmer’s Market Organic Sweet Potato Puree is smooth, naturally sweet, and rich in color. It provides an excellent base for your pie.
This organic puree is free from added sugars or preservatives. It allows the natural sweetness of the sweet potato to shine through. It’s perfect for crafting a wholesome and authentic sweet potato pie.
Using a premium puree ensures a consistent texture and deep flavor in your pie. It eliminates the need to boil and mash sweet potatoes yourself. This saves time without compromising on taste.
This is a mid-range ingredient that contributes significantly to the overall quality of your pie. Check Amazon for convenient multi-packs. It’s a top choice for one of the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
20. Natural Maple Extract (OliveNation)
For a unique twist on traditional Thanksgiving pies, consider adding maple extract. OliveNation Natural Maple Extract delivers a rich, authentic maple flavor. It can enhance pumpkin, pecan, or even apple pies.
This extract provides a concentrated maple essence without adding extra liquid or sweetness from syrup. It’s perfect for subtly infusing your fillings with that beloved autumnal taste. It’s a versatile flavoring agent.
A few drops can transform a standard recipe into something truly special. It adds a warm, comforting note that is perfect for the holiday season. This product is excellent for creative bakers.
This is a mid-range flavoring agent that offers great value due to its potency. You can find OliveNation extracts on Amazon. It’s a fantastic way to personalize your Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch.
—
Last Words
Crafting the best Thanksgiving pie recipes from scratch is a rewarding experience. It brings immense joy to your holiday table. This curated list of products offers a fantastic starting point for any baker. It helps ensure your homemade pies are nothing short of spectacular.
From essential baking tools like durable pie dishes and rolling pins to premium ingredients like organic pumpkin puree and pure vanilla extract, each item is chosen to enhance your baking journey. Remember, quality ingredients and reliable tools are the foundation of great results.
Whether you’re aiming for a classic pumpkin pie, a rich pecan pie, or a tangy Key lime pie, these selections will support your efforts. They help you achieve that perfect flaky crust and flavorful filling every time. You truly can’t go wrong with these top choices.
Consider your specific baking style and the types of pies you love most when making your selections. Each product offers unique benefits that can elevate your holiday baking. We encourage you to do further research on these items.
Take a moment to check current prices and availability on Amazon for these outstanding products. Equipping your kitchen with these items will undoubtedly inspire you to create many cherished memories, one delicious slice at a time. Happy baking!
About the Author
I dig until I hit truth, then I write about it. Diane here, covering whatever needs covering. Rock climbing clears my head; competitive Scrabble sharpens it. My engineering background means I actually read the studies I cite. British by birth, Canadian by choice.
